Tuesday, September 13, 2011

Turkish Criticism of Israel or Anti-semitism?

If Turkish PM Erdogan criticizes Israel, is it antisemitism?

Because of recent developments, Israel is again being accused of hypocrisy and attempting to deflect legitimate criticism of its policies, by claiming that its accusers are antisemitic. Erdogan himself recently made this claim in an interview. I think this warrants a cool headed analysis.

Firstly, let me state that disagreement with Israel's policies is legitimate and not intrinsically antisemitic. Within the Jewish and Israeli communities, we have highly charged and sometimes bitter disagreements about Israel's actions. Its is certainly completely acceptable for other countries to do so as well. When, however, does legitimate debate cross the line into racism and bigotry, of which antisemitism is a subset?

I think the question can by analysed on two levels:

1. Motive. Although we can never really know what resides in the hearts of men, the context and history of an accuser cannot be seperated from the content of his words. If Bin Laden was still alive and was to criticise Israel's blockade of Gaza, I don't think anybody could deny that his accusations are antisemitic. This is because of what governs his logic. He wants the blockade broken not because of humanitarian concerns, but rather because the Jews are infidels, he doesn't think that the Jew's state has a right to defend itself and because he wants harm to befall it. This would be antisemitism. Erdogan himself denies antisemitism and had not taken any actions against the Jews in his own country. Perhaps his motives are to restore Turkey's position as a regional superpower and to the glory of the days of old. We don't know for sure. One can suspect Muslim antisemitic instincts, but this would be hard to demonstrate objectively.

2. Content. Here is where I think Erdogan's claims fail. While Palestinian/Islamic rockets target civilians and fall on Israeli communities, he is conspicuously silent. The same goes for other terrorist attacks on Israel. No claims of "inhumane" behavior, terrorism, ignoring international laws, etc. He is not even a party to the conflict, as the Gazans are. Yet, when Israel takes any actions to defend the Jewish State from such attack (whether violent, such as the Gaza invasion, or non-violent, such as the blockade) , Erdogan calls us inhumane violators of international laws and child murderers, and that the naval blockade is a war crime. Setting aside for the moment that his statements are factually wrong (as evidence by the UN's Palmer report which Turkey itself agreed to), what we see here is the sign of a double standard. What is legitimate for the Palestinians (firing rockets) and for Turkey (attacking the Kurds), is illegal and immoral for the Israeli state, when attempting to protect Jews. This is pure hypocrisy, racism, and therefore antisemitic. Therefore Turkish denials of antisemitism are simply lies. True, it is veiled and subtle antisemitism, not foaming at the mouth Nazi-like propoganda. But its in the same league as Iranian President Ahmedinejad's holocaust-denying venom.

14 comments:

reginag said...

Im pretty sure it's a matter of religion. Nothing more.

krk realty

Fowl Ideas said...

Groups of people are more stable when they have an enemy to collectively fear and feel superior to.

Diamond said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Kendi said...

These articles are fantastic, The information you show us is interesting for everybody and is really good written, very informative. It’s just nice! continue posting. Thanks!

- Kendi of webdesign

Marx said...

Read a lot of blogs specially interesting ones like your blog, Good post! I accidentally found your site on the internet, I am going to be coming back here yet again.Love Information Is Beautiful. Keep posting!

- Marx of web design

Lama Obeid said...

Isn't Israel tired of using the accusation anti-semite? Especially against people of the Middle East who are also semites. Will someone please refer back to the dictionary meaning of semite before writing any articles concerning it. Thank you.

DrJ said...

I refer you to the definition of antisemitism:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antisemitism

Don't hide behind semantic games. Everybody knows what it means.

Genie said...

"One can suspect Muslim antisemitic instincts, but this would be hard to demonstrate objectively."

How ignorant. Unless you are an Arab Jew you are not a Semite to begin with. It's time to do away with that European definition of Semite. The Ashkanazi Jews invented the term for themselves to use the Semites as cover for their deception and fraud. You never hear the Semitic Jews ever use the term. Secondly, Islam originated with the Semites so hardly makes sense that Muslims would be inherently "anti Semitic". Thirdly, Israel is a colony state which makes everything about them a myth. A colony like to pretend it isn't a colony. Like America. We colonists are all from Europe, no sense in pretending we are not. Let's just say who we are and admit we've been lied to by the colonizers. It's not like they are doing us any favors.

دردشة ومنتديات عراقنا said...

اجمل دردشة عراقية رومنسية ترفيهية يظم كافة العراقيين والعرب والاجانب
شات عراقنا
دردشة عراقنا
جات عراقنا
شلة عراقنا
عراقنا
شات العراق
دردشة عراقية
شات كيكه
دردشة عبدالله
جات
دردشة
منتدى دردشة عراقنا
منتدى عراقنا
google

han yu said...

Because of recent developments, Israel is again being accused of hypocrisy and attempting to deflect legitimate criticism of its policies, by claiming that its accusers are antisemitic. Erdogan himself recently made this claim in an interview. I think this warrants a cool headed analysis.guild wars 2 gold
buy guild wars 2 gold
cheap guild wars 2 gold
cheapest guild wars 2 gold
guild wars 2 gold for sale

han yu said...

Because of recent developments, Israel is again being accused of hypocrisy and attempting to deflect legitimate criticism of its policies, by claiming that its accusers are antisemitic. Erdogan himself recently made this claim in an interview. I think this warrants a cool headed analysis.swtor gold
buy swtor gold
cheap swtor gold
tor credits
buy tor credits
cheap tor credits

love thomass said...

All's for the best in the best of all possible worlds! I have not see post good enough like yours here.Just admire your intelligence and informative explanation. I am a wow gamer but can't write such detailed info about that.
More tags: wow gold for cheap /
world of warcraft money /
gold for wow cheap /
cheap gold for wow

somnus11258 said...

When, however, does legitimate debate cross the line into racism and bigotry,You can learn more: China Travel Agency | China tour operator | China tour packages

Learn Chinese language on hanbridgemandarin said...

The best place to study mandarin online is in China. However, we understand that it isn't always possible to move here to study Chinese language. The next best thing is to study with our experienced teachers in a virtual classroom. Online students enjoy the same excellent way of mandarin online lesson and custom designed courseware that we provide for our face to face clients.